Socionics Personals
Female
Straight
16-25
Oceania
Libra
ENFj
Male
Straight
16-25
Middle East
Sagittarius
INTj
Male
Straight
26-35
North America
Pisces
INXj
Join now!


Questions & Answers
Question #1192959797Sunday, 21-Oct-2007
Category: ENTp Astrology
Is there any correlation between ENTPs and astrological sun signs? -- ENTP
Your Answers: 1+ 35+ 59+ 92+
A92 I'm an I(N)TJ born under the virgo sign. I've looked into greek, east indian, native indian, myian, chinese, and celtic astrology and found greek astrology is the first natural science and I consider it to be a theorhetical science unlike mysticism, i.e. pyschic mediums. To ignore all the fashion of modern greek astrology and focus on what makes it a science is clear: precision. Just like numerology, a single minute, hour or day can make a difference in how your personal astrology chart is created. Problematically, the celetisial position of the earth is not static and has shifted on its axis since greek astrology was first designed and another problem, with astrology, like numerology, is overdeterminism -the time and location of your birth determines your life; socionics avoids that problem by recognizing that duality, for instance, does not always occur due to non-socionic reasons. For making theorhetical comparisons there seems to be an inherent problem as socionics has sixteen types and greek astrology has twelve signs. Perhaps your sun sign correlates to your first function, ie. extroverted intuition, but then what of intertype relations? Cleary socionics and astrology are incompatible with each other. Likewise, I read that article on the coorelation between socioncis and ennigram systems, but again correlation does not equate to compatibilty as the ennagram system does explain intertype relations like socionics does. I've looked into palmistry as well - I have a water hand. Supposedly, some psychologist recognize the authencity of palmistry kinda like physionomics. Presently, I see water hands to extroverted intuition, fire hands to extroverted sensation, air hands to introverted inution and earth hands to introverted sensation. If your familar with Gulenko's terms: infantile = water, aggressor = fire, victim = air and caregiver = earth. That's not how I correlate but rather that's how I arranged it so it could be rearranged. -- Anonymous
A93 I'm an ENTP and my astrological sig(h)n is Mammoth. -- Nodder56
A94 ENTp and Cancer -- Anonymous
A95 enfp and sag here. -- Anonymous
A96 im an aquarius and entp. i have heard that there is some sort of connection but never really thought much of it. im just starting to learn about the personality typing process and the relations they have in every day life i think its kinda spooky how a majority of people who are aquarius are actually entp. and occasionally january people are enfp (my boyfriend and 5 friends) coincidence? enfp the next month is entp. i know odd match entp and enfp ha -- aquaruisentpandblonde. =/
A97 m aqurarious & my bf is also aquaroius v want to marry with each other... please whether it's gonna work.... i want to marry him only i can't live without him..& we both of us are of same caste.. bt then also i know it in advance only that my dad will never ever approve.. so plz tel wether are made for eachother -- rashmi shetty
A98 i'm an entp gemini. and i also took the test here. http://www.9types.com/newtest/homepage.actual.html i got type 7 the generalist followed in second place by type 8. all of them seem to correlate to each other -- geminiftw!
A99 Finding exact correlations between astrology and mbti is almost like comparing apples and oranges. I say almost, because they look at some of the same personality components, but from different perspectives, and in both there is an aspect of personality which is not addressed in the other system. Some would say that there is a correlation between the four elements and the four "mental muscles" fire-intuition, earth-sensing, air-thinking, water-feeling. However the definitions are somewhat different, and from different angles. For instance earth signs are supposed to be concerned with material possessions, physical pleasure, and will use systems proven by actual practice, while a sensing individual is someone who takes in information primarily through the senses, and perceives their world primarily in that realm. Both are have to deal with the physical world, but in different ways. I have found that astrological personality descriptions fit most of my friends and family, but not all. Though the fact that it is true for most I believe gives some credibility to the theory. As far as these personalities being caused by some mystical force I wouldn't put my money on it, but I do think that it is viable to ascertain that the 12 signs came about from careful study of personality traits found in people born during the same time of year. This would be considered a scientific endeavor, the conclusions from the findings may be far fetched, as far as the constellations themselves having some special power, but then again maybe not, I can't prove one way or another. If nothing else for those of you who think astrology is complete bull, I'd challenge you to look at it from a different angle. Separate it from being mystical and having to do with when you were born, and look at it as a personality theory where the 12 signs are combinations between Earth, Wind, Fire, Water....and Cardinal, Fixed, and Mutable. Look up the definitions of these, then look at personality profiles, you might find it interesting. Myself I am an ENTP and an Aquarius. I noticed there are quite a few ENTPs on this forum, it's probably because we tend to have a more open mind toward things, and can see things from other perspectives easily. -- Anonymous
A100 Too much fun in the sun = sunburn. -- Anonymous
A101 my ENTP friend is leo, they're usually fire or extroverted signs -- elle
A102 Aquarius and ENTp -- thefreed
A103 ENTP Aries here sucka! -- Anonymous
A104 Any sign can be an ENTp. Seriously, think about it. But there is at least some correlation between stereotypical air sign traits and ENTp traits. -- ENTj
A105 ENTP and I have Cancer. However, INTJ and Virgo seem a good match to me... -- Anonymous
A106 no -- ENTp female
A107 I think that it seems that ENTp are into astrology! I am an ENFP and a Libra. The profile of Libra does fit me quite well. -- Anonymous
A108 I'd like more info myself on the matter. Just curious. ISTP type, Sag sun, Cancer moon, Scorpio rising -- mh
A109 I'm an INFj, who happens to be a Psychotherapist and my ENTp husband happens to be a Marketer (surprising outcome for both, huh?). We met in our teens and now are in our mid 30's. From many, many years of observing him, I'd say there just might be a correlation- He is a Libra, the scales,all the extremes with no balance, yet one who strives for harmony. His proclivity to "improve" everything around him to find that perfect balance has been a source of both exciting times and frustrating ones for me for years. And speaking of the scales of justice, his strong belief in moral justice over his personal pleasure or happiness makes him rather Don Quixote-esque. So there seems to be a correlation at least for my ENTp -- Anonymous
A110 You know,the funny thing is I've been looking this up and it seems there's actually a fair number of INTj's that have devoted whole forums to this topic. why is this? I mean if it's all BS? BTW, I googled "free natal chart" and came across a good site that was eerily right in line with the personality type for everyone I know. I would like to direct the ENTp that originally asked this question in all seriousness and had it hijacked to look it up. Come on people, let's refocus. -- Serendipity
A111 ENTP and Aquarius -- Anonymous
Bookmark and Share

A112 My brother is ENTP and is Aquarius -- ENFPaggtarius
A113 ENTP and cancer/leo -- Anonymous
A114 INTP-Gemini-(5w6) I find NTP is much close to gemini: - N: Gemini is intuitive - T: Gemini is cerebral - P: Gemini is indecisive and a big information-gatherer However I always wondered if gemini and I(ntroverted) fit that much. -- Tommy
A115 I'm ENTP and aquarius. We have great similarities. -- Gravi
A116 I'm ENTP/ENFP and Sag -- Anonymous
A117 I'm an ENTP and an aires... I bet we will find each and every zodiac for ENTP, as for any other of the typology preferences... -- not Anonymous
A118 One's Sun Sign is only one facet of an astrological profile - the date, year, time of day, all factor in to determine the positions and aspects of all other planets/luminaries at the moment of birth, particularly the Ascendant (Rising Sign) and Moon, both of which can more significantly influence outward and inward personality characteristics than the Sun Sign. -- Sollucks
*Please note that the opinions expressed are not necessarily those of socionics.com*
Page 1 2 3 4
Would you like to add anything?
(When posting, we ask you to make the effort to qualify your opinions.)



Name: (leave blank for "Anonymous")

Related
 
10 Most recent
By category
All questions
Submit a question