of the 16 types is the right one.
The first feeling one could get from the picture is that John is not an ENTP. The facial features, such as the eyes, eyebrows, forehead, nose, cheeks, cheekbones, mouth, chin and their combinations, indicate that this person is likely to be ExFP, which means John could be either ENFP or ESFP.
Because of this particular single photographic shot it is difficult to determine whether John is S or N. However, the facial features give a strong indication that this is an F person.
A secondary feeling one could get from the picture is that John has a slight Logical-Sensory Intratim look about him. Often, such similarity in appearance happens between conflicting types. In this case Logical-Sensory Intratim and ENFP are the types, which share conflicting relations.
The next step is to analyse John's profile.
"..He wanted to make positive changes to the business but felt that the traditional bureaucratic culture he operated in prevented this. He was frustrated with how things were done, and believed that the rules and procedures he was expected to adhere to did not provide enough variety and scope for innovation.."
This mainly indicates that John's disappointment with rules and procedures quite strongly defines irrationality, in other words - P.
"..In the feedback session it he said that he enjoys working with others rather than alone, is enthusiastic and energetic, and actively seeks opportunities for change. He is flexible, spontaneous and adaptable, enjoys strategic thinking and logical analysis, and prefers to use an objective approach to implement long-term solutions for people. This Type is known as Extravert, Intuitive, Thinking, Perceiving (ENTP).."
Extrovert - yes, Irrational (P) - yes, Intuitive - possible, Thinking - not at all. Enthusiastic and energetic (E + F), enjoys working with others (E + F), long-term solutions for people (N + F) show that this person is very well defined F type. The fact that John enjoys strategic thinking and logical analysis does not mean that he is a Thinking type. ENFPs and ESFPs are very sensitive about their logical thinking abilities as well as about their knowledge. This over-sensitivity does not just boost their natural curiosity in these questions but also in some cases may lead them to choose their careers in such fields of activity.
"..His main occupational theme was 'Investigative' showing that he is interested in jobs involving science, research and logical analysis.."
Does 'Investigative' really mean science, logical analysis, etc.? A newspaper reporter is very 'Investigative' profession and would fit very nicely with an ENFP type.
"..Scientific jobs such as research and development fit the criteria, and although John found them very appealing, he deemed them impractical because they mostly require specific expertise or qualification that he did not want to pursue at this stage in his life.."
Doesn't it just prove the point above?
"..John eventually found a managerial role in public relations company that fitted well with his personality and work style - a fast-moving environment, where people value new approaches and initiative, and where his personal development is supported.."
The bottom line is that John was quite lucky to not to take all these MBTI® suggestions into account but instead just followed his own gut-feeling. However, if you were to ask John what is his type, he would tell you that he is ENTP.
|
Your Comments: 1+ |
C1 I know it should come out from ourselves,but being unable to decide i *really* need external orientation on careers that fit me best.i am INTp would you make sugestions on correlations: Socionic type-career -- Dex |
C2 C1 i don't know what type you are but if your looking for your best career, try and find one which calls for your strongest two functions. This is what your best at so you'll be best at this type of job. Thats what I think, don't know if moderator can suggest something better? -- Anonymous |
C3 so, INFj or INFp are not good physicists? But INTx and ENTx are? -- Anonymous |
C4 I think typing someone based on a photography leads commonly to mistyping. Your analysis is at best plausible but you need to document and argue your points a little more to convince me this guy is not ENTP. Just because he gets frustrated at his job and is now working in PR or HR doesn't mean anything... I know some ENTP who seems ENFP so much, but ENFP are much more unconditional in their attitude towards people fundamentally, whereas ENTP are very critical even if they don't openly show it. I don't see why an ENTP wouldn't find these work conditions stifling as well, and I have seen ENTPs just as frustrated like the guy in the picture. -- ENFP |
C5 I definitly do not think he is an ENTp. I happen to be an ENTp and while I do agree that some of his interests match mine, his overall personality is too social and not analytical enough. -- ENTp |
C6 In my opinion, male NF types feel social pressure to be more "masculine", i.e. more T rather than F. This is exacerbated in ESFP and ENFP type males, because they have a harder time being aware of their middle functions, which "get married" behind the scenes and act in concert as a mash-up of Fi and Te. http://alanaroberts.wordpress.com/2012/12/27/the-downfall-of-the-champion/ My blog article on ENFP downfall... hah it makes sense that as an INTj I would notice my supervisee type's downfall. In arguments with males who claim to be ENTP I often notice that they are unable to follow my logic and bring out very emotional, self-centered, idealistic arguments instead, which they believe to be stone-cold rational. My favorites are 1. substituting an emotional adjective for an argument and 2. substituting a statement of self-image for an argument. I have to laugh and move on though the temptation is to endlessly correct. I do think these guys are ENFP's. If they were ENTP's their T function would be the same as mine, though less prominent. -- AR |
Page 1 |
Would you like to add anything? |